I know from personal experiences that math textbooks can be super helpful but also very confusing. I remember explicitly that my AP Statistics textbook was one of the most challenging texts I have ever read. Nothing in the textbook ever made sense to me, it was all just black squiggles on a page. I noticed throughout the course of that class that I comprehended the material better when my teacher gave us a different platform to read from other than the textbook. Anything was better than reading that textbook, whether it was a worksheet, story, note page, powerpoint. Anything. I think that if we, as teachers, can adopt different platforms and teach from many different literacy texts, we can do better job of reaching all students no matter their reading level or learning strategy. Subject Matters states that “It’s more important to be vigilant, to be on the lookout for new materials that might suit our students better” (Daniels and Zemelman 201). Moving away from textbooks and into more interesting, relatable texts will engage more students and allow students to better understand more challenging material.
285
Kaylie Herbert
Such an interesting blog, Kaylie. I'm really interested in learning more about why you found the textbook so repulsive. Was it just a particularly bad textbook? Were you projecting onto that textbook prior experiences with textbooks? Both? Something else? Of course, it's easy enough to simply supply students with alternative modes of information, which is great, but I also think it's important to try to work out what was so wrong with that book! Doing so might help you more effectively select materials/readings for your future students. -BR
ReplyDelete